earticle

논문검색

硏究論文

파견과 도급 구별 기준에 관한 비판적 검토 - 대상판결 : 광주고법 2016.8.17, 2013나1128로 -

원문정보

A critical review of dispatch and subcontract classification criteria

김영문

피인용수 : 0(자료제공 : 네이버학술정보)

초록

영어

The criteria that distinguish dispatch from subcontracts have been made by case law. Most judgments distinguish dispatch from subcontracting on five criteria. However, the recent Gwangju High Court ruling is based on whether a subcontractor's worker has been transferred to the workplace of the original contractors and whether he has provided labor based on his command. This article critically reviewed it. Integration is not an independent distinctionscriteria, but merely the result of the directive exercise. Even if the integration is the criteria for dispatching and subcontracting, it should be regarded as being incorporated into the labor organization, not transferring it to the workplace. As a result, it is crucial whether the directionsright are exercised by the original contractors. However, it is necessary to distinguish between the directive for the subcontracting purpose and the labor law directive. If the original contractor completes the work specification and the subcontractor completes the work standards and the worker works as it is, the contract contents and actual work are consistent with each other. It should be seen that the legal relationship as contracted is done. The German Federal Labor Court takes this position. However, the judgment of our country affirms the dispatching relationship as it is determined that the contents of the work and the method of work are determined by the original contractors and accordingly, when the workers are working, the direction of the original contractors is given. In this case, the judiciary actually ignored the contracts of the parties and enforced the legal form. The enforcement of such a form of law should not be unreasonably recognized. The judiciary should not pursue legislation

목차

I. 들어가며
II. 검토
III. 결론을 대신하여
참고문헌

저자정보

  • 김영문 Kim, Youngmun. 전북대학교 법학전문대학원.

참고문헌

자료제공 : 네이버학술정보

    함께 이용한 논문

      ※ 기관로그인 시 무료 이용이 가능합니다.

      • 13,200원

      0개의 논문이 장바구니에 담겼습니다.