earticle

영어

In the current economic circumstance, industry standards play an important role for business and consumers, widely understood as one of the instruments leading the modern economy. Standards can make products more valuable to consumers because of interoperability among products following the same standard. They, thus, can widen consumer choice and increase social efficiency. However, it is reported that a standard could make innovation retarded by requiring significant additional costs to switch to alternative standard after the standard has been adopted. In particular, if a patent proprietor covers the technology required to implement the standard, he/she can exploit users of the technology by appropriate excessive royalty or royalty discrimination between competitors of the patent holder. For this reason, SSO requires those members to disclose patent information of potential standard technologies and FRAND commitment before publicize the standard. Unfortunately, such disclosure rules can be avoided and a SSO member can exclude substitute technologies and dominate a relevant market of the technology incorporated the standard in the standard-setting process. In this situation, the SSO member’s violating disclosure rules of SSO can be condemned as exclusionary anticompetitive behavior and, thus, establish the infringement of antitrust law. However, a monopolist's act interrupting antitrust law must harm the competitive process, rather than one or more competitors. For this reason, the antitrust plaintiff, the Government as plaintiff-that bears the burden of proving the causation between an exclusionary practice and anticompetitive effect of the monopolist's conduct. In the context of standardization process, the infringement of the rule of disclosing IP should be considered as general causation of monopolization of the standard technology. For this conclusion, SSO’s patent policy requiring disclosure of IP in the standard technology should show the scope of the disclosing duty and the result of indolence of the duty.